• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Scale FinanceScale Finance Logo, Interim CFO, Part Time CFO Services, Accounting Support, Temporary CFO, Accounting Bookkeeping Services

Interim CFO, Part Time CFO Services, Accounting Support, Temporary CFO, Accounting Bookkeeping Services

Charlotte · Raleigh – Durham · Chapel Hill · Triad · Southern Pines · Coastal Carolina
Closing the GAAP to Scale Your Business
The FINACA Logo
919-230-4667
Scale Finance, LLC, Financing, North Myrtle Beach, SC
  • Home
  • Services
    • CFO & Controller Services
    • Capital Raise Services
    • Business Valuations
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Professional Consultations at No Cost
  • Professionals
    • Partners
    • Charlotte Team
    • Raleigh – Durham – Chapel Hill Team
    • Greensboro-Southern Pines
    • Coastal Carolina Team
  • Client Experience
    • Closed Capital Raise Transactions
    • Closed M&A Transactions
    • Client Endorsements
    • Information Technology
    • Healthcare, Biopharma & Medical Device
    • Services, Energy, Industrial
    • Consumer, Retail, Media
    • Real Estate
    • Private Equity Groups
  • Recent News
  • Knowledge Bank
    • Best Practices in Scaling Companies
    • Entrepreneurial Management Skill- Building
    • Financial Management
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Regulatory Developments
    • Venture Capital
  • Contact Us
    • Charlotte
    • Raleigh – Durham – Chapel Hill
    • Triad – Southern Pines
    • Coastal Carolina
  • Joining Our Firm

When to Use Fairness Opinions in Private Transactions

Source: Billy Fink , Marketing Analyst, Axial

Disagreements about valuations are a dime a dozen — and fairness opinions can be a great way to preempt any dispute-turned-lawsuit.

Most often, fairness opinions are associated with public transactions. As John Leo of Primary Capital explained, “It is a business dominated by public companies because the real defining issue is whether or not minority shareholders are receiving fair value and being treated in an equitable manner.” He continued, “In order to address the [potential] conflict, companies get a fairness opinion from an independent third party; it is really an insurance policy.”

However, while the majority of fairness opinions are still conducted for public transactions, an increasing number are being employed in middle market private transactions as overall deal-related litigation is on the rise.

Two transactions that can often benefit with the presence of a fairness opinion are Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) and control recaps.

ESOPs

One of the most common private transactions to utilize fairness opinions is the ESOP. As Matthew Morris of RGL Advisors recently explained, “In an ESOP, the employees of the company typically receive stock holdings in the company as part of their compensation for work performed. Shares are held in trust until the employee retires or leaves the company, at which time the shares are sold. A trustee is designated to represent the interests of the ESOP trust and votes in business matters on behalf of the ESOP trust and its employee beneficiaries.”

Because there is one trustee managing multiple shareholders, the execution of a fairness opinion can be particularly important. Morris continued, “When an offer for a purchase or merger is made, the trustee must exercise fiduciary duty on behalf of the ESOP. In these transactions, the risk of dispute can be higher than a private company deal involving just one or two shareholders. A fairness opinion can help demonstrate that fiduciary duty was executed in good faith and can reduce the chance of shareholder dispute resulting from the transaction.”

As the acquisition of ESOP-associated businesses becomes more popular among middle market PE firms, the understanding and use of fairness opinions is more critical.

Control Recaps

Another private transaction that often warrants a fairness opinion is a control recap. “Control recaps give the private equity firm a controlling interest in the company, but leaves a substantial shareholder in play,” explained Morris. “While this might be financially or strategically prudent at the time of the investment, in a subsequent sale, the process of separating financial interests can be made more complicated.”

He continued, “This is particularly true if there is a disagreement between the majority and minority shareholder(s) about the terms of a transaction. Again, the fairness opinion can help demonstrate the exercise of fiduciary duty to better withstand subsequent challenges.”

Leo agreed, “As more and more private companies move up the food chain and attract private equity investors, it would be prudent to get a fairness opinion when they do a similar transaction.”

But, there’s more…

While Leo agreed that fairness opinions were more relevant for certain middle market transactions, they should be a consideration for nearly any deal. “If there is any potential conflict of interest, it’s always prudent to get a fairness opinion. Any M&A transaction where the issuer is purchasing or selling an asset from/to a related party should include a fairness opinion,” he explained. “The related party could be an officer, a director, large shareholder, or an affiliate.”

While it may seem like a burden at the time, “If you are doing an acquisition under $100 million, it is typically going to be much more financially efficient to pay for a fairness opinion upfront rather than have a legal battle later on with a handful of shareholders that dispute the value of the transaction,” explained Leo. “If you go to court with multiple shareholders, you will have to face several law firms and can easily incur hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees.”

Despite the time and cost that may be associated with a fairness opinion, it will be the better alternative to any legal battle.

About Scale Finance

Scale Finance LLC (www.scalefinance.com) provides contract CFO services, Controller solutions, and support in raising capital, or executing M&A transactions, to entrepreneurial companies. The firm specializes in cost-effective financial reporting, budgeting & forecasting, implementing controls, complex modeling, business valuations, and other financial management, and provides strategic help for companies raising growth capital or considering M&A/recapitalization opportunities. Most of the firm’s clients are growing technology, healthcare, business services, consumer, and industrial companies at various stages of development from start-up to tens of millions in annual revenue. Scale Finance LLC has offices throughout the southeast including Charlotte, Raleigh/Durham, Greensboro, Wilmington, Washington D.C. and South Florida with a team of more than 40 professionals serving more than 100 companies throughout the region.

Primary Sidebar

Knowledge Bank

Can Accountants Value a Business?

Personal Guarantees – Should You Grant One?

10 Pieces of Advice When Someone Wants to Buy Your Company

Convertible Note Financing – Payback Time

Due Diligence Fiasco – A Look Back at HP-Autonomy

Applying for Business Loans – Hard Credit Checks

Understanding the True Cost of Employee Turnover

How to Think About Valuation When Raising Venture Capital

What it Takes to Shift to a Recurring Revenue Model in Hardware & Software

Differences Between Major SBA Loan Programs – SBA 7(a) vs. SBA 504

5 Reasons Entrepreneurs Don’t Get Funded (Which Are Not Their Fault)

Balancing Profitability Versus Growth

Bootstrapping Your SaaS Business – What’s Changing

Best Options for Small Company Loans

Loan Workouts – Understanding Various Options

How to Value a Fintech Startup

The Value of Angel Investors

Finance & Accounting 101 for New Small Company Owners

How to Handle a Bank’s Rejection of Your Loan Request

Accessing University IP – Negotiating Financial & Other Terms

Explore the Knowledge Bank…

Secondary Sidebar

Recent News

Scale Finance Advises on Acquisition of Falcone Crawl Space & Structural Repair

Congrats to Payzer for Closing $23 Million Equity Financing

SF Client Headbands of Hope Closes Strategic Growth Investment

SF Assists Semper Investment Company in Acquisition of ACM Removal

SF Client SentryOne Acquired by SolarWinds (NYSE: SWI)

Scale Finance Assists GPM with Acquisition by Netsmart

SF Client Broadstep Behavioral Health Continues National Growth Through Acquisitions

SF Client Impact Financial Systems (IFS) Acquired by iPipeline

Scale Finance Assists TrueLearn with Investment by LLR Partners

Scale Finance Assists Textum Weaving with Investment by Quad-C

Scale Finance Closes Debt Financing for Horizon Eye Care

Scale Finance Closes Acquisition of Horsepower Site Services by MCG Civil

Scale Finance Closes Growth Financing for Celerity

Scale Finance Advises on Acquisition of Reliant Transport

Scale Finance Closes $20 Million ABL Financing for TRA

SF Client TruPoint Partners Acquired by Ncontracts

Scale Finance Advises on Debt Financing for Alpha Waste Industries, Inc.

More News…

Footer

Media

Scale Finance Managing Director Dave Gilroy interviewed on WSIC Radio (local Fox affiliate)

/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/David-Gilroy-Interview-Local-Biz-Now-2-7-14.mp3

Entrepreneurial Tips

  • Funding Tips from Scale Finance
  • CIE Life Sciences Panel Discussion
  • Why Use Fractional CFO Services

Sign Up—Finance Bulletin

Monthly insights into corporate finance for entrepreneurial companies

Sending

FINACA is a nationwide network of independent finance and accounting consulting firms focused on delivering exceptional client service.

FINACA is a nationwide network of independent finance and accounting consulting firms focused on delivering exceptional client service.

Return to top of page

Copyright © 2008–2023 Scale Finance, LLC
Securities and offering services through Charles Towne Securities, LLC. Members FINRA and SIPC.