• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Scale FinanceScale Finance Logo, Interim CFO, Part Time CFO Services, Accounting Support, Temporary CFO, Accounting Bookkeeping Services

Interim CFO, Part Time CFO Services, Accounting Support, Temporary CFO, Accounting Bookkeeping Services

Charlotte · Raleigh – Durham · Chapel Hill · Triad · Southern Pines · Coastal Carolina
Closing the GAAP to Scale Your Business
The FINACA Logo
919-230-4667
Scale Finance, LLC, Financing, North Myrtle Beach, SC
  • Home
  • Services
    • CFO & Controller Services
    • Capital Raise Services
    • Business Valuations
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Professional Consultations at No Cost
  • Professionals
    • Partners
    • Charlotte Team
    • Raleigh – Durham – Chapel Hill Team
    • Greensboro-Southern Pines
    • Coastal Carolina Team
  • Client Experience
    • Closed Capital Raise Transactions
    • Closed M&A Transactions
    • Client Endorsements
    • Information Technology
    • Healthcare, Biopharma & Medical Device
    • Services, Energy, Industrial
    • Consumer, Retail, Media
    • Real Estate
    • Private Equity Groups
  • Recent News
  • Knowledge Bank
    • Best Practices in Scaling Companies
    • Entrepreneurial Management Skill- Building
    • Financial Management
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Regulatory Developments
    • Venture Capital
  • Contact Us
    • Charlotte
    • Raleigh – Durham – Chapel Hill
    • Triad – Southern Pines
    • Coastal Carolina
  • Joining Our Firm

Will IPOs Ever Return to the Middle Market?

Source: Billy Fink, Editor, Axial Forum

IPOs are in vogue right now. In the last month alone there was the best IPO week since 2006 and PE IPOs reached their highest ever level.

But, not all companies are getting access to the IPO party. These flotations have largely been reserved for much larger firms, with significant market caps.

The small- and medium-sized businesses have largely been ignored in the IPO market for years. And chances are — due to regulatory concerns, investor preferences, and the increasing effectiveness of the private capital markets — the smaller IPO will not return.

Here’s why…

Compliance Challenges

In a recent interview, Marc Andreessen explained that regulatory burdens are one of the primary reasons that IPOs became unfeasible for smaller companies.

“The compliance and reporting requirements are extremely burdensome for a small company,” explained Andreessen. “It requires fleets of lawyers and accountants who come in and do years of work.” While these regulations are intended to protect the small company, he believes it has “the opposite effect.”

Andreessen is primarily referring to the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (aka Sarbox), whose controversial Section 404 dealt a blow to small company IPOs. The section was so problematic that the SEC learned that 70% of small companies considered going private again after Sarbox’s Section 404 was implemented in 2002.

While compliance may have driven down the small company IPO, it isn’t these regulations that are keeping smaller IPOs dead. After all, the JOBS Act modified Section 404 to be more accommodating for small firms. The results have been underwhelming. As Steven Davidoff and Paul Rose explained in their research paper on The Disappearing Small IPO, “Percentagewise, the number of small IPOs [in 2013] was one of the lowest since 1996. The trend instead is toward ever larger IPOs. The number of large IPOs was the largest since at least 1996.”

Investor Savviness

If not regulation, then what killed the small IPO? Many pundits point to investor savviness as a factor in the demise. Back in the 1990s, the primary investor in a company’s IPO was an individual. Today, hedge funds and mutual funds dominate the stage.

As Andreessen continued in his interview, “The problem is the shareholder base itself has changed dramatically. You’ve had a dramatic rise in hedge funds. Very short-term trading and dramatic rise in short-selling. If you’re a public company, you become the shuttlecock between warring longs and shorts. They bat your stock around like it’s a chew toy.”

Axial Member Tom Courtney, of The Courtney Group, identified a similarly important impact from mutual funds. “Most mutual fund managers do not want to own more than 5% of a company (because they have to report it to the SEC) and want to be able to sell a position in 3-5 days without moving the price of the stock. Add to this the economics of the mutual fund business, that an equity mutual fund typically becomes a profitable business at around $200 million in assets under management (charging 1% a year for expenses) and you can calculate that a stock must have a market capitalization of about $300 million.”

The changing nature of the average public investor made the opportunity for small- and mid-cap companies much less appealing. Since these savvier investors cared less about smaller IPOs, these companies received less coverage from analysts and were traded less frequently. As a result, many of small companies in the public market became unprofitable. The consequence of poor trading can still be felt today — just look at Crumbs’ recent bankruptcy.

Since the mass return of the individual investor to the stock market is unlikely, these developments in investor habits have proven much more problematic – and permanent — for the smaller IPO than the more transient regulatory matters.

The Growing Effectiveness of M&A

Although shifting regulations and investors accelerated the initial decline in small company IPOs, the primary factor that has kept small companies off the public markets is the effectiveness of the private capital markets and M&A.

Over the past twenty years, there has been an explosion of deal professionals around the United States. The growing number of private equity firms, search funds, investment banks, and M&A advisors has dramatically increased a private company’s ability to tap into the private capital markets. The opportunities have only improved as technologies — like Axial, AngelList, etc. – have developed.

Many business owners and entrepreneurs have realized that partnering with financial sponsors or strategic acquirers can offer comparable opportunities as an IPO, without the additional headaches or risks. As a result, even if the investors and regulators changed back, many private companies would still remain private.

As John C. Coffee, Jr. explained, “Issuers conduct IPOs for multiple reasons: (1) to raise capital; (2) to create a public market and give their founders liquidity; and (3) to generate the highest valuation for their firm through the efforts of underwriters.” With a slight exception for #2, partnering with the right financial sponsor or strategic acquirer can be just as effective as going public.

The fact that SMBs are favoring a first stop at the private capital markets can be seen in the amount of capital raised by a company before it goes public. The companies that went public over the last four years had raised on average more than $70M pre-IPO, leaving many of them simply too large to be acquired. After raising that much money, you generally are seeking a $250-1B+ exit, which is well beyond the means of most strategic and PE acquirers. As such, the only option still available is an IPO.

The appeal of staying private has become even more important in recent years. As baby boomers begin to retire, they are concerned about the legacy of their business, and are seeking strategies that can ensure a dynasty of their choosing. Choosing the buyer/investor of their business can help secure that strategy.

About Scale Finance

Scale Finance LLC (www.scalefinance.com) provides contract CFO services, Controller solutions, and support in raising capital, or executing M&A transactions, to entrepreneurial companies. The firm specializes in cost-effective financial reporting, budgeting & forecasting, implementing controls, complex modeling, business valuations, and other financial management, and provides strategic help for companies raising growth capital or considering M&A/recapitalization opportunities. Most of the firm’s clients are growing technology, healthcare, business services, consumer, and industrial companies at various stages of development from start-up to tens of millions in annual revenue. Scale Finance LLC has offices throughout the southeast including Charlotte, Raleigh/Durham, Greensboro, Wilmington, Washington D.C. and South Florida with a team of more than 40 professionals serving more than 100 companies throughout the region.

Primary Sidebar

Knowledge Bank

5 Rules for an A+ Board Meeting for Investor-backed Companies

Understanding & Using Your Cash Flow Statement

Why Business Valuations are Helpful (& What do they Typically Cost)?

Managing Merchant Fees – Role of Zero Fee Processing

Can Accountants Value a Business?

Personal Guarantees – Should You Grant One?

10 Pieces of Advice When Someone Wants to Buy Your Company

Convertible Note Financing – Payback Time

Due Diligence Fiasco – A Look Back at HP-Autonomy

Applying for Business Loans – Hard Credit Checks

7 Ways a Business Name Generator Can Help Entrepreneurs

Citizenship by Investment Overview

Understanding the True Cost of Employee Turnover

How to Think About Valuation When Raising Venture Capital

What it Takes to Shift to a Recurring Revenue Model in Hardware & Software

Differences Between Major SBA Loan Programs – SBA 7(a) vs. SBA 504

5 Reasons Entrepreneurs Don’t Get Funded (Which Are Not Their Fault)

Balancing Profitability Versus Growth

Bootstrapping Your SaaS Business – What’s Changing

Best Options for Small Company Loans

Explore the Knowledge Bank…

Secondary Sidebar

Recent News

SF Closes Acquisition of Midwest Outdoor Resorts for Travel Resorts of America

Scale Finance Advises FX HedgePool on $8M Series A Funding

Scale Finance Closes $7 Million Senior Debt Financing for Travel Resorts of America

Scale Finance Advises on Acquisition of Falcone Crawl Space & Structural Repair

Congrats to Payzer for Closing $23 Million Equity Financing

SF Client Headbands of Hope Closes Strategic Growth Investment

SF Assists Semper Investment Company in Acquisition of ACM Removal

SF Client SentryOne Acquired by SolarWinds (NYSE: SWI)

Scale Finance Assists GPM with Acquisition by Netsmart

SF Client Broadstep Behavioral Health Continues National Growth Through Acquisitions

SF Client Impact Financial Systems (IFS) Acquired by iPipeline

Scale Finance Assists TrueLearn with Investment by LLR Partners

Scale Finance Assists Textum Weaving with Investment by Quad-C

Scale Finance Closes Debt Financing for Horizon Eye Care

Scale Finance Closes Acquisition of Horsepower Site Services by MCG Civil

Scale Finance Closes Growth Financing for Celerity

Scale Finance Advises on Acquisition of Reliant Transport

More News…

Footer

Media

Scale Finance Managing Director Dave Gilroy interviewed on WSIC Radio (local Fox affiliate)

/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/David-Gilroy-Interview-Local-Biz-Now-2-7-14.mp3

Entrepreneurial Tips

  • Funding Tips from Scale Finance
  • CIE Life Sciences Panel Discussion
  • Why Use Fractional CFO Services

Sign Up—Finance Bulletin

Monthly insights into corporate finance for entrepreneurial companies

Sending

FINACA is a nationwide network of independent finance and accounting consulting firms focused on delivering exceptional client service.

FINACA is a nationwide network of independent finance and accounting consulting firms focused on delivering exceptional client service.

Return to top of page

Copyright © 2008–2023 Scale Finance, LLC
Securities and offering services through Charles Towne Securities, LLC. Members FINRA and SIPC.